The series “His Hour and His History” opens the wounds of Naira Ashraf and causes controversy

The events of the series revolve around various true stories from Egyptian court records and it is not a “story”.Naira Ashraf“Only, but it’s the most prominent story, which has caused widespread controversy, especially after her sister Shoruk threatened to stop airing episodes of the series because she appeared in a video confirming that those responsible for the work will be sued. after the pain that the news caused to all family members.

Speaking during the clip, “Shorouk” condemned the show’s appearance on the painful accident that her sister “Naira” suffered and wondered: “Where did they get the information that will appear in the show and the author or director did not speak to any of the family members .”

The great art critic Samir El-Gamal believes that drama is responsible for what happened to Naira Ashraf, when she produced works like “Awlad Rizk”, “Abda Muta”, “Ibrahim Al-Abiad” and others.

He said in exclusive statements to “Sky News Arabia” that everything that is currently being initiated in relation to the story of the series, promotional clips and talks about filing a lawsuit against the creators of the series is nothing more than a means to promote and publicize the work. , indicating that the series must be watched before judging it as a whole.

Camilla continued that Art He is the one who influences and leads, and the street imitates. He gave, for example, a quote from a prominent artist, Adel Imam, who said in one of his old dramas, “The Land of True Testimonies,” how has this phrase affected the generations so far? He explained that the wounds are certainly still in the hearts of the victim’s family and friends and will remain so, emphasizing the importance of a dramatic treatment that we have not seen before.

He said that issues of public opinion become the property of society, and creators have the right to work on them, otherwise we would not see works like “Raja and Sakina”, “Al-Safa” and others.

For his part, Dr. Says: Doaa Ibrahim Al-Sayed, a mental health consultant, told Sky News Arabia that Naira Ashraf is an example of girls who are exposed to violence despite all the progress society has made and strict laws and punishments.

She adds that a large number of girls fall into the trap of a masculinity complex and the feeling of being rejected by some men. Because it reminds him of the mental image he had from his youth due to several factors, which were ingrained in him as a result of male society, so how could any girl, no matter who she was, reject him?! Consequently, his reaction is extremely violent and can even lead to murder, as we have seen in the case of the Mansoura girl.

She points out that Naira Ashraf’s case was not and will not be the only one or the last, because the same fate befell many others, but the cameras did not catch it.

Al-Sayed believes that Naira’s family has the right to demand that the series be stopped, which is sure to open wounds that have barely healed, noting that the absence of information may result in the portrayal of unreal events, raising the level of controversy again. , either in Naira’s case, or other cases that the series “His Hour and His History” is expected to deal with those events.